“Do
you believe in God?”[1]
We have asked the question, and the question has probably been asked of us.
This question, interestingly, seems to pop up in any and all venues of
life—around a campfire, at a dinner party, in the middle of a family gathering.
For some, one’s response is a matter of curiosity and for others a litmus test—for
friendship, further conversation, or something else.
Some
will simply and easily answer the question, “Sure! Of course….” And others will
quickly peel off with questions regarding what we mean by “God” or dive into a
discussion about how we might understand God—deistically, theistically,
personally, etc. Fortunately, or unfortunately, responding to this question of
belief requires about as much intellectual and religious fortitude or rigor as
responding to, “Do you like vanilla ice cream?”
Here
at the outset, better that this writer come clean on his background: a
bachelor’s degree in English (that means in college reading a lot and reading
broadly—one course during the senior year required 21 books…and those to be
read in 15-week semester! [Honestly not every word of those books was read, but
main ideas were grasped…and the existence of “Cliff Notes” much appreciated.].That
degree would be more accurately described as a degree in literature or letters rather
than merely “English.”); a master’s degree in English as well…plus three more
master’s degrees beyond that (yes, four in total); finally, a doctorate in
theology (Th.D.)—and the bibliography of that 222-page dissertation goes on for
ten pages. All this not to boast but to convey that your writer here has read
deeply and broadly, has grappled with the great questions of life and death,
meaning and purpose, and…God.
Changing
the Question
Now,
we propose that the question we have been asking—“Do you believe in God?”—is
both intellectually weak and religiously shallow—it is an easy question for
anyone of any religious tradition or of no religious tradition. And, in our
North American culture, we can believe in anything, and that belief can
have absolutely no effect on our general thinking or behavior. We all believe that fast food kills us, but the lines remain long in those joints day in and day out. “Belief,” mere
intellectual assent, is easy for us. So, I suggest we begin asking a better,
more revealing, and deeply thoughtful question: “Do you want there to be a God,
do you want God to exist—why or why not?” Yes, the question is a bit longer,
but such a question changes things a bit—hopefully requiring a deeper dive into
the motivations of belief.
“Do
you want there to be a God, do you want God to exist—why or why not?” Those who
answer in the affirmative will often be those who crave meaning or purpose. If
God exists, then we exist on purpose…and, therefore, we exist with purpose. We live and breathe for a reason
(more on this below). We who answer “yes!” to this line of questioning hope
beyond hope that there is a Being or a Power who takes an interest in us, that
Someone or Something cares for us, One who just may have the power and desire to
positively impact the trajectory of our lives. We who cling to this reality of
God want to know that our lives extend beyond our relatively short-lived
bodies, that this God will preserve and animate something about us (soul,
personality, spirit) long after our limited, frail, imperfect bodies are buried
or burned. We who want God to be often are looking for an order to this
existence and to this world and to this universe…an order that somehow mirrors
the natural laws that seem to operate around us.
“Do
you want there to be a God, do you want God to exist—why or why not?” The
self-proclaimed atheist may very well say “no” to this question.[2]
Many of those who answer in the negative to our proposed question are not
people who do not want someone (Someone?) to care for them—they would like that
very much. These are not people who reject some sort of order in the
universe—they happily embrace the natural laws that indicate an apparent order in
world around us. Rather, many of those who almost joyfully reject the existence
of God really want to reject the responsibility, our responsibility, that comes
with assent to the existence of God. With a God-created reality and its natural
law comes a universal moral law—a way of being and acting woven into the very
fabric of the universe. But if there is no God, one can easily cast off what
can be perceived as the weighty responsibility of life in a God-created, God-ordered
universe. If there is a God, we very well may have to own up to our actions and
explain ourselves at some point, or we may have to anticipate consequences for
our thoughts and behavior. But if there is no God, ahhhh…well, we can simply
live as we please—no responsibility, no eternal or soul-significant consequences,
no worries.
Camus
and his existentialist friends argue that we simply create our own purpose in
life since no deity exists to impose a purpose or order on things. Okay. But
that just means we become gods unto ourselves (rather weak and pathetic gods in
the end), and if we wake up one rainy, cold morning and simply don’t feel like
living up to our self-created and self-imposed standards, we can just take the
day off. Responsibility is temporal…fluid, fickle, and relatively consequence-free.
Living with no real God that we have to respond to makes life easier in some
ways…at least in our own minds. We can let go of guilt and other irritating
feelings. However, the day will come, the time will come—in a moment of loss,
disaster, or as we come to the end of this life—when our atheist friends and
family will suddenly, desperately hope that Someone or Something cares for us, that
some power might act on our behalf, that there is more to existence than the
paltry 80+/- years that life on earth may afford us.
Universal Moral Law?
C.S.
Lewis, N.T. Wright, and others (generally, writers who use initials rather than
names—we need to remember that...and maybe this author now becomes J.A.
Herrin...hmmm) have argued rather effectively[3]
for the existence of a moral law that vibrates throughout the universe. Our
understanding of this moral law has changed just as our understanding of
natural laws have changed. Just as Copernicus and Galileo brought about a
seismic shift of understanding (they did not change reality; only our understanding)
as they enabled us to grasp and perceive that the sun, moon, stars and
everything else do not revolve around the earth but that the earth is simply
one of billions of bodies engaged in various revolutions around other heavenly
bodies, so Jesus of Nazareth brought about a seismic shift of understanding as
he revealed that the old conception of moral law that insisted on “an eye for
an eye” and “a tooth for a tooth” (rex talionis) falls short of the
greater moral law of agape that we find in the New Testament—a determination
to put others before ourselves, to act on the behalf of others, to live lives
of forgiveness and kindness in the face of whatever the world throws at us.[4]
Jesus declares that “all the Law and the prophets” (the moral law of the day)
comes together in the “greatest commandment”—“You shall love (agape) the LORD your God…and your neighbor (the person near you, the person you
can impact or touch) as your self.” We have a moral responsibility—an ability
to respond—to God the Creator of all things, to those around us who are in need,
and even to ourselves and our own needs. We have a responsibility to God, to
others, and to self.
Lives of Purpose--
Towards the beginning of this piece, we say that wanting there to
be a God, wanting God to exist, is often a deep desire for purpose and meaning
in our lives. As much as we would like to find meaning in our social media
posts and the number of “likes” that come in, that and the many other places we
strive to find purpose and meaning all just leave us wanting. When we look at
the Jewish and Christian scriptures—those collected centuries of writings that reflect
people grappling with divine and existential questions, we find a thread
running through it all—even in those times and pages of the rex talionis.
We find that God—in all of these pages and stories and laws and prophecies and
teachings—longs for one thing above all else: Life. In Old Testament Hebrew,
the term is nefesh, and in New Testament Greek, the term is zoe.
Both of these terms indicate being alive, but they indicate so much more—they
indicate a life of meaning and purpose. In the beginning, God breathes into the
first humans the breath of life (nefesh) (Gen. 2:7)[5].
Moses, leading the Israelites out of slavery in Egypt, calls on the people—they
are already alive, mind you—to “choose life” (nefesh) (Deut. 30:19).
Jesus declares to his disciples—also already alive—that he has come that they
may “have life (zoe), and have it to the full” (John 10:10).
Interestingly (and probably significantly), zoe appears in the New
Testament more often than agape. Nefesh/Zoe seems, from the
record, to be the thing God (if God exists) desires for us more than anything
else. And, when we go back and read the record of scripture with this in mind,
we find that the Law of the Old Testament and the Sermon on the Mount of the
New Testament (and all the other writings that guide and tell us how to live)
are simply guiding us towards finding that real, full, and purposeful life.
Characteristically counter-intuitive of Christian teaching and theology, the
message of scripture, of the Gospel, of the Bible is this: We find
life—meaningful, purposeful, lasting life—when we help others find life. When
we live life to the full and help others do the same (notice, we cannot embrace
only self-interest—part of that universal moral law), we are fulfilling the
wish and purpose and desire of God for us. The overarching moral law of the
universe is life...Life!...LIFE!
Verdict?
Do you want there to be a God? Do you want God to exist? If God’s
existence means the responsibility of living life to the full and enabling
others to do the same, does the existence of God seem so onerous, backwards,
stifling? If the existence of God means the possibility or probability that
“life” does not end with our bodies, that we exist with purpose and meaning,
that Someone or Something creates and cares for us, that a universal moral law
does exist and that law is neither burdensome nor life-sucking nor joy-robbing
but quite the opposite—if all of these are likely, would we not want God to be?
In the end, many of us have embraced the reality of a God we do not (cannot?) fully
know or understand, and we have embraced the moral law that permeates scripture
and the universe…as far as we understand it. And, as Frost puts it, in doing so—embracing
the welcome reality of God—“that has made all the difference.”[6]
So, for you, God or no God?
Jon A Herrin serves as lead pastor of the McAllen First United Methodist Church in McAllen, Texas. He was raised as a missionary kid in Guyana (South America) and Grenada (West Indies). Herrin later completed graduate studies in English, Education, and Theology/Biblical Studies, and he served an English/Humanities/Theology professor for over 25 years. His areas of writing include theology and biblical studies, teaching and learning, and Christian living. He is the author of numerous articles and books, including Genesis Speaks Today (Border Life Press, 2026), Suffering: Conversations Old & New (Border Life Press, 2025), and Making Sense of It All (KDP, 2020). He and his wife, Jeanne, served as long-term lCross-Cultural Missioners in Venezuela and Mexico, and now live and serve in the Rio Grande Valley of south Texas on the US/Mexico border. Learn more about Herrin here:
www.jonherrinwriter.com
https://substack.com/@jonaherrin
https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61569377107843
https://edinburgseminary.academia.edu/JonHerrin
https://jonpredica.blogspot.com/
[1] Your author is a Christian in the Wesleyan
stream, so his concepts and understandings of God are formed by his reading of
the Christian scriptures, his tradition, reason, and experience. In most
general terms, God is the benign, life-giving Creator or all that is.
[2] The “no” of many God-deniers are those who struggle
deeply with the idea of a “good” God who allows suffering. They seem incapable
of recognizing that suffering is directly tied to our amazing gift of free will
and the probable or actual existence of evil/evil forces in this world. The
author tackles God, suffering, evil, and more in very accessible depth in Suffering:
Conversations Old & New (Border Life Press, 2025). Others who say “no”
may have been deeply harmed by the Church—generally perceived as an institution
that should reflect the love and grace and care of God...but too often has/does
not.
[3] See C.S. Lewis’ Mere Christianity
(HarperCollins, 2001) and N.T. Wright’s Simply Christian (HarperCollins,
2010).
[4] Yes…a long sentence. Feel free to re-read
if you need to. 😊
[5] Some have argued that this act, this moment,
indicates the coming of consciousness, the moment that these bipedal creatures
of Creation become self-aware and thus able to care for self and others, and
able to respond to the Creator.
[6] Robert Frost, “The Road Not Taken.” Poetry
Foundation. https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/44272/the-road-not-taken
